He's got better and more comfortable with every game he has played, so glad TP brought him in and switched Wardy to left back....Although Moxey started the season well I feel both he and Parr are a little out of their depth at this level.

Scoring goals for Palace...Oops, sorry, I've got the wrong defender, I meant John Terry

I think he's been really good since he arrived and is really learning the role of a full back, he gets forward a lot better recently, his defensive game is very good.

Adrian M is very lucky to be in the side. He gets caught out on pace many times but is able to foul his way to safety. Definitely knows how not to get booked

changed my seat on sat and was near front of the Arthur so had a good look at him 1st half.

He did a decent job but is pretty ordinary. Going forward likes an extra touch and often declines to cross but kept it simple and rarely lost possession.

Defensively he did ok but has a tendency to drift inside (near the centre backs) when villa are attacking down the other side.

He's decent back up at both centre and right back but for over £2m thought we might be getting more for our money.

Has definitely improved overall though - at Wigan in the cup he was a complete liability.

Not trying ot have a pop, just saying it as i see it.

Yup

Is that not Pulis's style of defending? A narrow back four with the wingers tucking in... I think he's been superb and really hasn't received the credit he deserves. Gets forward really well and can defend too.

Dont let Cabaye go