This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Register | Edit Profile | Subscriptions | Forum Rules | Log In
|  A1969Eagle  Redhill 07 Feb 19 7.26pm |    | 
|---|---|
| Salah is dreading VAR Originally posted by davenotamonkey 
 All I can say is: it will make things that little bit harder for Liverpool. What a farce today. Goal + Origi's effort at the end. And then Klopp afterwards whinging at the officials? Absolutely unreal! [Tweet Link]
 | |
|  Alert a moderator to this post |     | 
|  southnorwoodhill  07 Feb 19 8.13pm |    | 
|---|---|
| Originally posted by YT 
 It'll just mean 3 cvnts making biased decisions against the like of us and in favour of the likes of 'them', rather than just 1. But it will be fully in the media spotlight. Crap refereeing (in theory) will definitely be called out. Edited by southnorwoodhill (07 Feb 2019 8.21pm) 
 | |
|  Alert a moderator to this post |     | 
|  YT  Oxford 07 Feb 19 8.41pm |    | 
|---|---|
| Originally posted by southnorwoodhill 
 But it will be fully in the media spotlight. Crap refereeing (in theory) will definitely be called out. Edited by southnorwoodhill (07 Feb 2019 8.21pm) My point is why should the 3 refs in the video room be any less biased? 
 Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) | |
|  Alert a moderator to this post |     | 
|  Pierre  Purley 13 Feb 19 11.36am |    | 
|---|---|
| I cannot understand why VAR requires 3 officials in a room to make decisions. Surely this in itself lengthens the debate/discussion and therefore impacts on the decision time! Other sports manage perfectly well with only one whom the referee refers to for clarification. 
 | |
|  Alert a moderator to this post |     | 
|  blackheatheagle  Beckenham 13 Feb 19 2.10pm |    | 
|---|---|
| Originally posted by Pierre 
 I cannot understand why VAR requires 3 officials in a room to make decisions. Surely this in itself lengthens the debate/discussion and therefore impacts on the decision time! Other sports manage perfectly well with only one whom the referee refers to for clarification. I guess the main idea is to have concurrence to avoid any debates that if the decision (to check the incident in VAR) was fair or not. VAR is used in my home country and even if there are 3 people, still there are complaints `why VAR was checked for a penalty claim` etc. It just supports that it is a decision of jury, not a single person. VAR creates a new type of complaint which is `why didn`t referee ask to VAR`? 
 
 | |
|  Alert a moderator to this post |     | 
|  Tickled pink  Cornwall 13 Feb 19 8.37pm |    | 
|---|---|
| Originally posted by A1969Eagle 
 Salah is dreading VAR Eventually offside will be dealt solely by VAR and linesman will have more time to do their other things properly, too many mistakes in almost every single game. 
 | |
|  Alert a moderator to this post |     | 
|  Tickled pink  Cornwall 13 Feb 19 8.39pm |    | 
|---|---|
| Kevin Friend, rings a bell  
 | |
|  Alert a moderator to this post |     | 
|  Phil’s Barber  Crowborough 24 Feb 19 9.33pm |    | 
|---|---|
| Watching the Levante v RMA game this evening...after yet another ridiculous VAR decision (RMA second penalty) this just reinforces my belief that we are in for the most incredulous decisions that will do absolutely nothing to resolve some of the shocking refereeing decisions we have to suffer. How they can ‘review’ that incident and still decide it’s a penalty is absolutely beyond me! Pathetic!  
 | |
|  Alert a moderator to this post |     | 
|  Phil’s Barber  Crowborough 24 Feb 19 10.19pm |    | 
|---|---|
| Link 
 | |
|  Alert a moderator to this post |     | 
|  Rachid Rachid Rachid  24 Feb 19 10.37pm |    | 
|---|---|
| Absolute rubbish. Killing the moment and still plenty of poor decisions anyway. Too much to the detriment of the paying fan. Trying to perfect and make a precise science of something that isn’t even down to the ridiculous imaginary lines they draw across the pitch to decide whether a player’s toe is offside. Honestly think the game is being run by idiots. Edited by Rachid Rachid Rachid (24 Feb 2019 10.38pm) 
 | |
|  Alert a moderator to this post |     | 
|  bifffabazz  Highworth, Wiltshire 25 Feb 19 6.49am |    | 
|---|---|
| Originally posted by Phil’s Barber 
 Watching the Levante v RMA game this evening...after yet another ridiculous VAR decision (RMA second penalty) this just reinforces my belief that we are in for the most incredulous decisions that will do absolutely nothing to resolve some of the shocking refereeing decisions we have to suffer. How they can ‘review’ that incident and still decide it’s a penalty is absolutely beyond me! Pathetic!  Agreed. The VAR ‘team’ must be have been smoking something (paid for by Madrid). Absolutely shocking. UEFA need to step in (unless they’re taking bungs too!) 
 Spirit of 1974 | |
|  Alert a moderator to this post |     | 
|  Willo  South coast - west of Brighton. 25 Feb 19 9.24am |    | 
|---|---|
| I can only re-iterate that VAR will not be a panacea in that subjective decisions will be made in certain instances and there will still be controversy. 
 | |
|  Alert a moderator to this post |     | 
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.